Type to search

Analysts Wary Despite China’s Factory, Consumption Growth

Holiday spending is likely to have boosted the latest factory and retail data for October, according to analysts, who say a proper recovery is still elusive

People line the streets in Shanghai on the National Day holiday. Photo: Reuters


China’s industrial output hit 4.6% in October, according to new data from the National Bureau of Statistics on Wednesday, which was just over the 4.5% seen in September, and the strongest since April.

Retail sales also improved, rising 7.6% year-on-year in the month on better auto and restaurant sales. That figure was up from 5.5% in September and the fastest since May.

Analysts had expected retail sales to grow 7.0% due to the low base effect in 2022 when Covid curbs disrupted consumers and businesses.

However, the underlying economic picture has significant pockets of weakness, with the property sector continuing to hinder a full-blown revival, while local government debt risks, slow global growth and geopolitical tensions have held back momentum. A flurry of policy support measures have proven only modestly beneficial, raising pressure on authorities to roll out more stimulus.


ALSO SEE: China Plans New Checks For Auditors, Accounting Firms


Consumers concerned about jobs, income growth

Analysts struck a cautious note on the upside data surprise, noting that the property sector remains weak and pointed to the lack of major reforms as another impediment to sustainable longer term revival in growth.

“Due to the impact of holidays and low base effect in 2022, year-on-year figures cannot reflect the actual momentum of the economy,” Xing Zhaopeng, senior China strategist at ANZ, said.

He said month-on-month figures suggest economic momentum has further weakened with “increasing deflationary risks”.

Louise Loo, China economist at Oxford Economics, said prolonged weakness in external demand could hamper industrial production despite strengthening last month as destocking pressures eased further.

Consumption didn’t make much headway either during the eight-day Golden Week holiday earlier in October. Trips made in that period missed government estimate as economists say consumers are concerned about their jobs and income growth in an uncertain employment market.

The nationwide survey-based jobless rate stayed at 5.0% in October, unchanged from September, the NBS data showed. Youth unemployment, which hit a record high 21.3% in June, wasn’t available after the statistics bureau stopped publishing it since July.

China has been ramping up efforts to revive its post-Covid economy with a slew of policy support measures in recent months, although the positive effects have been marginal so far.

Wednesday’s upbeat data comes as a raft of other indicators for October released over recent weeks pointed to muted growth momentum. Imports grew unexpectedly, but exports shrank at a quicker pace, household borrowing remained weak, consumer prices swung lower while factory deflation persisted.

Authorities are faced with a challenging task as any aggressive monetary support would further widen interest rate differentials between China and the West, especially the United States, and dent an already weakened yuan. That could intensify capital outflows, while Beijing is wary of a return to the big-bang fiscal stimulus of the past which created massive debt and hamstrung the economy.

The economy grew faster-than-expected in the third quarter, with analysts generally expecting it to reach the government’s full-year growth target of around 5%, though a full-blown recovery is still some time away.

The yuan held near a more than two-month high after surprisingly softer US inflation reading overnight boosted bets that the Federal Reserve had reached the end of its tightening cycle.


Property, investment disappoint

The country’s central bank, People’s Bank of China (PBOC), boosted liquidity injections but kept the interest rate unchanged when rolling over maturing medium-term policy loans on Wednesday.

In a rare revision last month, the government also lifted its 2023 budget deficit to around 3.8% of gross domestic product from 3% to account for the planned issuance of 1 trillion yuan ($137 billion) in sovereign bonds.

The PBOC has cut banks’ reserve requirement ratio (RRR) twice this year to free up liquidity to aid the economic recovery. Analysts widely expect another RRR cut and an interest rate cut in the final months of this year.

China’s crisis-hit property sector has yet to see a meaningful rebound despite strengthened support measures for homebuyers, including relaxing of home purchase restrictions, lowering in borrowing costs and other programmes.

Property investment fell 9.3% in January-October year-on-year, after a similarly sharp 9.1% drop in January-September.

Fixed asset investment disappointed with a 2.9% expansion year-on-year in the first 10 months, missing expectations for a 3.1% rise. It grew 3.1% in the January-September period.

Confidence among private businesses also remained depressed, with investment in the sector shrinking 0.5% during January-October, narrowing slightly from the 0.6% decline in the first nine months.

“Overall, the data published today suggest that the recovery was struggling to gain a strong footing at the start of Q4, but it was not nearly as weak as some had feared,” said Sheana Yue, China economist at Capital Economics.

“Policy looks set to remain supportive, and possibly even stepped up to prevent the economy from backsliding.”


  • Reuters with additional editing by Jim Pollard




China to Issue More Government Bonds to Tackle Debt Crisis


China Turns Focus on Rare Earths Sector Amid Trade War with US


China Facing Reality Check After Long Boom Built on Debt


Multiple Moves Needed to Defuse China’s Local Debt Crises



Jim Pollard

Jim Pollard is an Australian journalist based in Thailand since 1999. He worked for News Ltd papers in Sydney, Perth, London and Melbourne before travelling through SE Asia in the late 90s. He was a senior editor at The Nation for 17+ years.


AF China Bond