Type to search

Easing ‘Zero Covid’ Policy Could Cause 2m Deaths: China Study

Chinese scientists and health specialists stress the need for stringent controls, saying transmission risks are too high and that mass infection would put intolerable pressure on health systems

Medical workers in protective suits collect swabs from residents during a citywide nucleic acid testing after cases of the coronavirus in Zhengzhou, Henan province. Photo: Reuters


Restoring normal population mobility to “Covid-zero regions” like China would cause some 2 million deaths in a year, Chinese researchers have claimed. They said the key to controlling the virus is developing vaccines that are better at preventing infection.

China’s “zero-Covid” restrictions have come under growing scrutiny in recent weeks as it hosts the Winter Olympics in Beijing while using sweeping restrictions to try to prevent the spread of the more infectious Omicron variant.

Chinese scientists and public health specialists have reiterated the need for maintaining the stringent controls, saying the risks of transmission were too high and that mass infection would put intolerable pressure on the health system.

The researchers used studies from Chile and Britain to calculate the “baseline efficacy” of current vaccines – CoronaVac in the case of Chile and the Pfizer and Oxford/AstraZeneca shots in Britain.

They estimated the baseline efficacy against symptomatic disease of the vaccines was 68.3%. They estimated the baseline efficacy of existing vaccines against death was 86%.

The efficacy estimate against infection is based on British data and efficacy against symptomatic disease and deaths was based on data extracted from a study on Sinovac’s CoronaVac in Chile.

But even with a global vaccination rate of 95%, if population mobility was restored to 2019 levels, the researchers estimated that all Covid-zero regions would see more than 234 million infections within a year, including 64 million symptomatic cases and 2 million deaths.

“The human race should continue to develop vaccines and explore new ways to improve vaccine protection against infection in order to eliminate Covid-19 at the global level,” the team of Chinese scientists said in a paper, published on Friday in the weekly bulletin of the China Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CCDC).

In order to reduce the incidence of Covid-19 to the levels of influenza after restoring normal mobility, the efficacy of vaccines against infection needs to be increased to 40% and the efficacy against symptomatic disease needs to be increased to 90%, they said.


Preventing Infection ‘More Important’

They said it was more important for new vaccines to be effective against infection than against symptomatic disease or death.

“The key to controlling Covid-19 lies in the development and widespread use of vaccines that are more effective at preventing infection,” the team said.

China is the only major economy sticking with a zero-Covid policy despite warnings that it could hurt growth. Other states, like Singapore, Australia and New Zealand, have abandoned the strategy in favour of what policymakers call “learning to live with Covid.”

China has doubled down on its zero-Covid message and continues to seal off entire cities, the latest being Baise in the southern region of Guangxi. The Beijing Winter Olympics are being held in a “closed-loop” bubble that some athletes have branded as excessive.

“We previously thought Covid-19 could be basically contained through vaccines but now it seems that there’s no simple method to control it except with comprehensive measures,” the CCDC’s chief epidemiologist Wu Zunyou told the Communist Party-run Global Times on Sunday.


• Reuters with additional editing by Jim Pollard



China Locks Down City on Vietnam Border as Covid Cases Rise


China’s Zero Covid Policy to Unsettle Markets This Year: Eurasia


China’s Xi’an Locks Down 13m Residents, Warriors Over Covid


China Study Warns of Huge Covid Outbreak If It Opens Up



Jim Pollard

Jim Pollard is an Australian journalist based in Thailand since 1999. He worked for News Ltd papers in Sydney, Perth, London and Melbourne before travelling through SE Asia in the late 90s. He was a senior editor at The Nation for 17+ years.


AF China Bond