China Entrepreneurs Face Grim Future, Says Beijing Academic


China’s crackdown on entrepreneurs has been prompted by them shunning the help of state-owned enterprises and displaying too much independence, according to a Renmin University scholar based in Beijing.

The private sector, especially technology and new economy startups, rely on founders’ entrepreneurial genius and international investors rather than Communist Party connections and partnerships with state agencies, Martin Miszerak argued in a weekend essay.

The academic said he analysed the companies targeted – including taxi-hailing platform DiDi, Alibaba affiliate Ant Financial, entertainment streaming service Tencent, food delivery platform Meituan and e-commerce company – and concluded it was a coordinated policy.

The most likely explanation for the crackdown is that it is “an assault on China’s entrepreneurial private sector”, he said in the essay, published by the East Asia Forum, a think tank.

Beijing is closing the distance between the establishment and entrepreneurs by cracking down on their ventures and interrupting their business models.

“This distance from the state is being disrupted by the crackdown through which the Chinese Communist Party is moving to solidify political control over corporate cash flow,” Miszerak, a visiting lecturer at Renmin Business School, said.


Transparent Corporate Structure

Companies such as DiDi Global unnerved China’s ruling class with their “extremely slim and transparent” corporate structure, compared with bloated and inefficient state-owned enterprises (SOEs).

“Few state-affiliated investors participated in DiDi’s earlier fundraising rounds, as its founders have always sought to raise capital from world-famous names such as Apple, Temasek and Alibaba,” Miszerak said.

Miszerak said the policy was most likely instigated by Xi Jinping, China’s top leader.

“One interpretation of [China’s crackdown] is that the campaign is part of Xi’s strategy to steer China towards a Maoist model of governance in which the private sector is significantly downsized and private companies are likely to lose what is left of their independence and become mere appendages of the state,” he said.

The signal by Liu He, China’s vice-premier, that the government intended to end its ‘regulatory rectification’ campaign suggested that Xi had “finally awoken to the damage” the year-long crackdown has wrought on investor sentiment, Miszerak said.

But China’s crackdown shows entrepreneurial companies have paid a steep price for their independence, he said.

Although Ant Group might be allowed to proceed with its much-delayed public offering on the Hong Kong stock exchange, regulators are pushing for a corporate restructuring in which Ant Financial will take on SOEs as partners.

“It remains unclear how DiDi’s case will unfold, but much can be learnt from looking back on Jack Ma’s experience with Ant Financial,” Miszerak said. “The future of China’s entrepreneurial capitalism looks decidedly grim.”


  • George Russell



Didi Seen in Talks For Stake in China EV Maker Sinomach

Ant Group Names HKEX Chair Laura Cha to Board

Alibaba Founder Jack Ma Reappears In Hong Kong



George Russell

George Russell is a freelance writer and editor based in Hong Kong who has lived in Asia since 1996. His work has been published in the Financial Times, The Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg, New York Post, Variety, Forbes and the South China Morning Post.

Recent Posts

China Quants Banking on AI to Gain Hedge Funds Edge

One hedge fund already uses ChatGPT to project earnings power, and identify investment opportunities and…

8 hours ago

Global Economy Showing Signs of De-Dollarisation, Says JPMorgan

"De-dollarisation is evident in FX reserves where [the dollar's] share has declined to a record…

10 hours ago

China Services Activity Speeds Up as Demand Recovers: Caixin

The survey saw firms reporting a rise in new business in May as China's Covid…

12 hours ago

Binance Controlled Bank Accounts of ‘Independent’ US Crypto Arm

New findings show how CEO Changpeng Zhao secretly retained control over Binance's US arm and…

12 hours ago

TSMC’s Tough Standards Could Hit Hunt for US Staff – Fortune

TSMC's workplace culture has come in for criticism by former workers, but the tech giant…

12 hours ago

Israel Likely to Play Big Role in Reducing AI Risks: Altman

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman predicted Israel, a country ranked high for machine learning systems, will…

13 hours ago