Persistent default fears eclipsed efforts by China Evergrande Group‘s chairman to lift confidence in the embattled firm on Tuesday, as Beijing showed no signs it would intervene to stem any domino effects across the global economy.
Analysts played down the threat of Evergrande’s troubles becoming the country’s “Lehman moment,” though concerns about the spillover risks of a messy collapse of what was once China’s top-selling property developer have roiled markets.
In an effort to revive battered confidence in the firm, Evergrande Chairman Hui Ka Yan (Xu Jiayin) said in a letter to staff the company is confident it will “walk out of its darkest moment” and deliver property projects as pledged.
In the letter, coinciding with China’s mid-autumn festival, the chairman of the debt-laden property developer, also said Evergrande will fulfil its responsibilities to property buyers, investors, partners and financial institutions.
“I firmly believe that with your concerted effort and hard work, Evergrande will walk out of its darkest moment, resume full-scale constructions as soon as possible,” he said, without elaborating how the company could achieve these objectives.
Investors in Evergrande, however, remained on edge.
The company’s shares fell as much as 7%, having tumbled 10% on Monday, on fears its $305 billion of debt could cause widespread losses in China’s financial system in the event of a collapse. The stock ended down 0.4%.
Other property stocks such as Sunac, China’s No.4 developer, and state-backed Greentown China on Tuesday recouped some of their hefty losses from the previous session. The Hong Kong property sector index rose nearly 3%.
‘SYSTEMIC RECAPITALISATION NEEDED’
“There must be negotiations behind the scenes about a systemic recapitalisation [of Evergrande] by state proxies,” said Andrew Collier, managing director of Hong Kong-based Orient Capital Research.
“If one piece of Evergrande’s debt is allowed to default, it would trigger questions about all of their remaining debt from investors and the government doesn’t want a wider crisis like that,” he said.
The Chinese government has been largely quiet on the crisis at Evergrande in recent weeks.
World stocks stabilised somewhat on Tuesday and oil prices recovered from the previous day’s heavy selling, as investors grew more confident that contagion from the distress of Evergrande would be limited.
However, the spillover concerns in the property sector remained. S&P Global Ratings downgraded Sinic Holdings to ‘CCC+’ on Tuesday, citing the Chinese developer’s failure “to communicate a clear repayment plan.”
Hong Kong-listed shares of small-sized Chinese developer Sinic plunged 87% on Monday, wiping $1.5 billion off its market value before trading was suspended.
A major test for Evergrande comes this week, with the firm due to pay $83.5 million in interest relating to its March 2022 bond on Thursday. It has another $47.5 million payment due on September 29 for March 2024 notes.
Both bonds would default if Evergrande fails to settle the interest within 30 days of the scheduled payment dates.
“I think [Evergrande’s] equity will be wiped out, the debt looks like it is in trouble and the Chinese government is going to break up this company,” said Andrew Left, founder of Citron Research and one of the world’s best known short-sellers.
“But I don’t think that this is going to be the straw that breaks the global economy’s back,” said Left, who in June 2012 published a report that said Evergrande was insolvent and had defrauded investors.
The Chinese government will help Evergrande at least get some capital, but it may have to sell some stakes to a third party, such as a state-owned enterprise, Dutch bank ING said in a research note.
“The spin-off of non-core businesses, for example, those that are not residential real estate type businesses, will probably be done first,” wrote Iris Pang, ING’s Chief Economist, Greater China.
“After that could come sales of stakes that are at the core of Evergrande’s business,” Pang said.
Citi analysts in a research note said that regulators may “buy time to digest” Evergrande’s non-performing loan problem by guiding banks not to withdraw credit and extend the interest payment deadline.
Still, Citi said that while Evergrande’s default crunch was a potential systemic risk to China’s financial system, it was not shaping up as “China’s Lehman moment.”
In any default scenario, Evergrande, teetering between a messy meltdown, a managed collapse or the less likely prospect of a bailout by Beijing, will need to restructure the bonds, but analysts expect a low recovery ratio for investors.
S&P Global Ratings said in a report on Monday it does not expect Beijing to provide any direct support to Evergrande.
“We believe Beijing would only be compelled to step in if there is a far-reaching contagion causing multiple major developers to fail and posing systemic risks to the economy,” the rating agency said.
“Evergrande failing alone would unlikely result in such a scenario,” S&P said.
• By Reuters with additional editing by Jim Pollard