Companies in Malaysia from palm oil plantations to semiconductor makers are rejecting orders worth billions of dollars as a shortfall of over a million migrant workers threatens the Southeast Asian country’s economic recovery.
Despite the government easing a Covid-19 freeze on hiring of foreign labour since February this year, the country hasn’t seen a return of migrant workers in the wake of a slow bureaucracy and long drawn-out negotiations with Indonesia and Bangladesh over worker rights, according to companies, industry lobbies and diplomats.
The export-reliant Southeast Asian nation, a key link in the global supply chain, relies on millions of foreigners for factory, plantation and service sector jobs shunned by locals as dirty, dangerous and difficult.
Manufacturers, who make up nearly one-fourth of the economy, fear losing customers to other countries as growth picks up.
“Despite the greater optimism in outlook and increase in sales, some companies are gravely hampered in their ability to fulfil orders,” said Soh Thian Lai, president of the Federation of Malaysian Manufacturers, which represents over 3,500 companies.
Palm oil growers are at breaking point, said Carl Bek-Nielsen, chief executive director of oil palm grower United Plantations.
“The situation is dire and very much like having to play a game of football against 11 men but only being allowed to field seven,” he said.
Malaysia lacks at least 1.2 million workers across manufacturing, plantation and construction, a shortage worsening daily as demand grows with an easing of the pandemic, industry and government data show.
Manufacturers say they are short 600,000 workers, construction needs 550,000, the palm oil industry reports a shortage of 120,000 workers, chipmakers lack 15,000 and cannot meet demand despite a global chip shortage, and medical glovemakers say they require 12,000 workers.
Malaysia’s manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index dropped to 50.1 in May from 51.6 in April, barely remaining in expansion, as the sector shed the most jobs since August 2020, according to data from S&P Global.
Chipmakers are turning away customers, locals are not interested in working in the industry and many who do join leave in less than half a year, says Wong Siew Hai, president of the Malaysia Semiconductor Industry Association.
The palm oil industry, which contributes 5% to Malaysia’s economy, warns 3 million tonnes of crop could be lost this year as fruit rots unpicked, meaning losses of more than $4 billion. The rubber glove industry estimates $700 million of lost revenue this year if the labour shortage persists.
Debt Bondage Fears
Malaysia’s Ministry of Human Resources, which is responsible for approving the intake of foreign workers, did not respond to Reuters queries for comment on the labour crunch and its economic impact.
In April, Minister M Saravanan said companies had asked to hire 475,000 migrant workers but the ministry had approved just 2,065, rejecting some for incomplete information or lack of compliance with regulations.
Diplomats from Indonesia and Bangladesh, two of Malaysia’s biggest sources of foreign labour, said workers’ rights were part of the hold-up in sourcing migrant workers.
Bangladesh signed an agreement in December to send workers, but implementation was delayed after Dhaka protested at Malaysia’s proposed hiring process, citing fears the plan could lead to increased costs for the workers and debt bondage, a Bangladeshi diplomatic source said.
“Our main focus is our workers’ welfare and rights,” Bangladesh’s expatriate welfare and overseas employment minister, Imran Ahmed said. “We’re making sure they get standard wages, they have proper accommodation, they spend minimum cost for migration and they get all other social security.”
He said Dhaka does not “want workers to end up falling into a cycle of debt trap”, adding that Malaysia wants to hire 200,000 Bangladeshi workers within a year.
The United States has banned seven Malaysian companies over the last two years over what Washington called forced labour.
Malaysia’s Saravanan, who was in Dhaka early this month, said Malaysia had given the Bangladesh government reassurances that it would ensure better salaries and protection of workers’ welfare. He has denied claims that the hiring process was flawed.
Saravanan said last week the government was finalising technical matters, recruitment procedures and agreements with some source countries.
Indonesia’s ambassador to Malaysia, Hermono, who like many Indonesians goes by a single name, said concerns over worker protection came up in recent bilateral talks.
- Reuters with additional editing by Sean OMeara
The headline on this report was changed on June 13, 2022.
US Imposes 7th Ban on Malaysian Glovemakers over Forced Labour
Malaysia Says It Will Ratify ILO Protocol to Fight Forced Labour
Dyson Ends Deal With Malaysia’s ATA Over Labour Concerns